🎭 Book Review: Both Things Are True by Kathleen Barber
A witty, heartfelt second-chance romance that explores love, scandal, and the messy truth behind curated lives.
Kathleen Barber, known for her suspenseful debut Truth Be Told, pivots to romantic comedy with Both Things Are True—a Reese’s Book Club pick that blends emotional depth with sharp humor. With a Goodreads rating of 3.72/5 from over 1,200 readers, this novel offers a fresh take on starting over when your past won’t stay buried.
💔 Plot Overview
Vanessa, a yoga influencer living in New York, is forced to flee the spotlight after her crypto-entrepreneur fiancé disappears amid fraud allegations. With her reputation in ruins, she returns to Chicago to live with her sister and regroup.
Just as she begins to rebuild her life, she bumps into Sam, her ex-husband from a whirlwind Vegas wedding years ago—officiated by a Dolly Parton impersonator, no less. Their relationship ended in heartbreak and a quick annulment, but the chemistry is still there. Sam now co-owns a solar company and has a promising future, one Vanessa wants to be part of—but her scandalous past threatens to derail everything.
💫 Why It Works
- Second-Chance Romance: Vanessa and Sam’s dynamic is full of tension, nostalgia, and emotional growth.
- Modern Themes: The novel explores internet fame, public shame, and the blurred lines between personal truth and public perception.
- Voicey & Fast-Paced: Barber’s writing is sharp and engaging, with plenty of twists and heartfelt moments.
- Sisterhood & Support: Vanessa’s relationship with her sister adds warmth and grounding to the story.
💬 Praise from Authors
- “A voicey wild ride full of lost love, deceit, sisterhood, and second chances.” —Ali Brady
- “A one-sitting read that fans of second-chance romances will absolutely love.” —Suzanne Park
- “Laugh, cry, and cringe all at once… utterly satisfying happily ever after.” —Meredith Schorr
🏁 Final Verdict
Both Things Are True is a smart, emotionally resonant romcom that balances scandal with sincerity. If you enjoy stories about flawed characters finding their way back to love—and themselves—this one’s worth the read.
