💔 Book Review: Both Things Are True by Kathleen Barber
A witty, heartfelt second-chance romance that explores the messy contradictions of love, scandal, and starting over in the age of internet fame.
Kathleen Barber, author of Truth Be Told (adapted into the Apple TV+ series starring Octavia Spencer), returns with Both Things Are True, a romantic comedy that blends emotional depth with sharp social commentary. With an early Goodreads rating of 3.72/5 from over 1,200 readers, the novel is already sparking conversation for its timely themes and relatable characters.
🧠 Plot Overview
Vanessa, a yoga influencer living in New York, is forced to flee the spotlight after her crypto-entrepreneur fiancé disappears amid fraud allegations. With her reputation in tatters, she returns to her hometown of Chicago, moving in with her sister and trying to rebuild her life.
Then she bumps into Sam, her ex-husband—yes, the one she married in Las Vegas on a whim, with a Dolly Parton impersonator officiating. Their relationship ended in heartbreak and a quick annulment, but the spark between them never fully died. Sam now co-owns a solar company and has a promising future, one Vanessa wants to be part of. But with scandal still clinging to her name, she’s torn between protecting Sam’s reputation and rekindling what they lost.
💬 Why Readers Are Intrigued
- Modern Romance with Depth: The story tackles fame, reputation, and the emotional fallout of public scandal.
- Voicey & Fast-Paced: Barber’s writing is sharp, funny, and emotionally resonant, making this a one-sitting read for many.
- Second-Chance Trope Done Right: Vanessa and Sam’s chemistry is undeniable, and their journey feels earned.
- Sisterhood & Self-Discovery: Vanessa’s relationship with her sister adds warmth and grounding to the story.
📣 Early Praise
- “A voicey wild ride full of lost love, deceit, sisterhood, and second chances.” — Ali Brady
- “Fans of second-chance romances will absolutely love it.” — Suzanne Park
- “Laugh, cry, and cringe all at once… a satisfying happily ever after.” — Meredith Schorr
🏁 Final Verdict
Both Things Are True is a smart, emotionally layered rom-com that captures the contradictions of modern love and identity. If you enjoy stories about redemption, fame fallout, and rekindled romance—with a dash of Dolly Parton flair—this one’s worth preordering.
