👭 Book Review: When We Were Friends: A Short Story by Jane Green (Kindle Edition)
A sharply observed, emotionally layered novella that explores the intoxicating highs—and unsettling lows—of female friendship. Jane Green delivers a cautionary tale wrapped in charm, wit, and psychological tension.
🧠 Overview
Published in October 2024 as part of Amazon Original Stories, When We Were Friends is a 44-page contemporary short story by Jane Green, the bestselling author known for her warm, character-driven novels like Jemima J and The Beach House. This story follows Lucy, a recently divorced woman who’s finally settling into her dream home and embracing a quieter, more grounded life.
Enter Elle—a younger, stylish woman who seems to share Lucy’s passions and instantly clicks with her. Their friendship blossoms quickly, but as Lucy introduces Elle to her social circle, cracks begin to show. Elle’s behavior shifts, and Lucy starts to question whether her new best friend is really who she claims to be.
🔍 Key Themes & Highlights
- 💔 Post-divorce reinvention: Lucy’s journey reflects the vulnerability and hope that come with starting over
- 🧠 Friendship red flags: Green masterfully captures the subtle signs of manipulation and emotional imbalance
- 🕵️♀️ Psychological suspense: The story builds tension through shifting dynamics and growing mistrust
- 🌿 Domestic realism: Lucy’s cozy, plant-filled home contrasts with the emotional chaos Elle brings
“By all accounts, Lucy’s handled her divorce well… But as Lucy introduces Elle to her circle, a new side of her friend appears. And try as she might, Lucy can’t ignore her misgivings.” — Goodreads summary
💬 Reader Reception
- ⭐ Goodreads rating: 3.45/5 from over 26,000 ratings
- 📖 Readers appreciate the story’s relatable premise, snappy pacing, and emotional realism
- 🧾 Some found the plot predictable, but most enjoyed the novella’s quick delivery and character-driven tension
- 💬 “It’s like that friend who shows up with wine and gossip—fun, fast, and a little unsettling.” — Bookishelf review
⚠️ Considerations
- 📄 Short format: At 44 pages, it’s a brisk read—perfect for a commute or cozy afternoon
- 📚 Standalone: No prior reading required, though fans of Jane Green will recognize her signature voice
- 🧠 Light suspense: More emotional drama than thriller—ideal for readers who enjoy domestic fiction with psychological undertones
🏁 Final Verdict
When We Were Friends is a smart, emotionally resonant novella that explores the complexities of female friendship and the dangers of ignoring your instincts. Jane Green’s writing is crisp and engaging, making this Kindle edition a satisfying pick for fans of contemporary fiction with a twist of psychological intrigue.
